Triage, by my book:
- Kane: 57 pts in 67, point-per-game after the break. Re-sign at the right number, short term. Skill like that doesn't grow on trees here.
- Perron: cheap depth scoring, keep if the AAV stays modest.
- JVR: fine veteran, replaceable.
- Talbot: 3.19 / .883 down the stretch, lost the net. Hard to justify a real raise. Let him walk.
- Gostisbehere: useful PP piece, depends entirely on term and price.
You genuinely cannot keep all five and stay flexible. Yzerman's right.